Customer interviews: four stages, starting with the decision you need to make

Customer interviews work when they start from a decision: plan around it, recruit people who do the work, ask about real past events, then check notes against it.

Instant Expert EditorialPublished Updated 6 min read

Customer interviews work best when they start from a decision you need to make and end by updating it. They are one-to-one conversations with people who have the problem you are working on, or who use or buy a product like yours, about what they actually did recently. They are the quickest way to learn how someone does a job, why they chose what they use and what it cost them when things went wrong.

A useful round has four stages: plan what you need to learn, recruit people who can tell you, run conversations about real past events, and analyze the notes against the decision.

A made-up example to follow through

Say you are building scheduling software for hotel housekeeping teams, and you need to decide whether to focus on independent hotels or small hotel groups first.

1. Plan around the decision, then write the questions

"Independent hotels or small groups first?" is a decision. The facts that would change it become your research questions: who builds the housekeeping schedule today, how long it takes, what goes wrong when someone calls in sick, and who would approve paying for a tool.

GOV.UK's research planning guidance recommends turning assumptions and opinions into research questions and ranking the most important ones. It suggests 4 to 8 participants per round for in-depth interviews, and several smaller rounds instead of one big one, so you can adjust after each.

For the hotels, that could be one round of six interviews: three housekeeping managers at independent hotels and three at small groups.

2. Recruit the person who does the work

Talk to whoever does the work or makes the decision you are asking about. A general manager may approve the purchase, but the housekeeping manager builds the schedule every morning. Titles vary, so ask early in the call whether they personally handle the task.

Where to look depends on whether you have customers yet. Existing customers, recent lost deals and people who cancelled are all useful and easy to reach. Before you have customers, find people doing the work through directories, event programs and people search. The operations professionals in hospitality directory page shows the kinds of people who might fit the hotel example.

3. Ask them to walk through a real morning

GOV.UK's guidance on in-depth interviews gives a practical structure. Get informed consent and explain the research. Start with a few easy questions about their job. Then work through your topics with open questions and simple follow-ups like "can you tell me more about...?" It recommends focusing on stories and real examples rather than how things should happen, staying quiet so the participant does most of the talking, and leaving time at the end for anything you did not understand.

In the hotel example, "Walk me through this morning's schedule, from when you arrived" gets you further than "How do you schedule housekeepers?" The first gets a specific morning, problems included. The second gets how it is supposed to work.

Keep two habits throughout. Ask about what already happened, not what someone would do in the future. And don't pitch your idea while you are still learning about the problem. People are polite, and praise for an idea tells you little about whether they would pay for it.

4. Analyze the notes against the decision

After each round, write down what each person did, in the same format, before drawing conclusions. Then compare. Do independent hotels and small groups handle sick calls differently, and does that difference matter for the decision? Mark each research question answered, still unclear or contradicted, and rewrite the next round's questions.

Which guide fixes which problem

ProblemStart here
Nobody replies to your invitationsWhy research outreach gets no replies
Every interview ends with "sounds great"Customer interview questions
You are unsure you are talking to the right personHow to interview B2B users, buyers and champions
You worry payment will bias answersPaying without paying for positive feedback
You need to know how common something isInterviews versus surveys
Your team doubts the findingsRun a research readout with skeptical stakeholders

Skip interviews when you need a count

Interviews explain reasons and processes for a handful of people, not how common something is across a market. Use a survey or existing data for that, after interviews have shown you what to count.

When the question is how an industry works rather than one person's experience, such as how hotel groups usually buy software, someone who has seen many cases may answer it faster. How to prepare for an expert interview covers that kind of call.

Book your first round

If you need interviewees outside your own network, search for people by describing the experience you need, for example "housekeeping managers at independent hotels with 50 to 150 rooms," or paste the LinkedIn URLs or emails of people you already have in mind. You approve every invitation before it goes out.

For the round of six, say you offer each manager $100 for a 30-minute call. With our fee on top, each booked call costs you $125, so the most the round can cost is $750 if all six book. Sending places a hold on your card for the priciest person's price, fee included, and you're charged for each person only when they book; declines and invitations nobody accepts cost nothing (how it works). Each manager has 7 days to pick a time, with up to two reminders, and doesn't need an account to book.

If someone asks to interview you

A housekeeping manager has what the hotel founder needs to learn, and a paid invitation says up front what the conversation is worth. It shows the founder's note and the amount you would receive, which is yours in full because our fee is charged to the founder on top. You can book a time, decline, or reply with the price you want; a counteroffer above the offer goes to the founder, and their answer comes back to you in the same thread. Payment goes out 24 hours after the call, by direct deposit, a gift card or a donation to a charity you pick, which we make for you. Every invitation has a link to stop future requests.

The four stages of a round of customer interviews

  1. 1

    Plan

    Write the decision, the facts that would change it, and who can speak to each.

  2. 2

    Recruit

    Invite people who personally do the work or make the decision.

  3. 3

    Run

    Ask them to walk through recent, specific events and follow up on what you don't understand.

  4. 4

    Analyze

    Compare accounts in one format and mark each question answered, unclear or contradicted.

Each round starts from a decision and ends by updating it. The next round's questions come from whatever is still unclear.