Jobs to be done, explained: why a milkshake's real rival is a banana

Jobs to be done says customers hire products to make progress in a situation. Here are B2B examples, the four forces behind a switch and an interview guide.

Instant Expert EditorialPublished Updated 6 min read

Jobs to be done (JTBD) explains why people buy better than demographics do. Customers "hire" a product to make progress in a particular situation, and "fire" it when it does that job badly. So you study the situation and struggle behind a purchase, and you learn the job by interviewing people who recently switched to, or away from, a way of doing something.

The idea: you are competing with whatever gets hired today

Clayton Christensen, Taddy Hall, Karen Dillon and David S. Duncan summarized the theory in the Harvard Business Review article Know Your Customers' "Jobs to Be Done" (September 2016). Their argument: product developers focus too much on customer profiles and data correlations. When we buy a product we "hire" it to do a job, and "fire" it if it does the job poorly. Jobs have social and emotional sides as well as functional ones, and the circumstances in which customers try to get a job done matter more than who the buyers are.

The Christensen Institute describes JTBD as a lens on the circumstances, or forces, that push people and organizations toward and away from decisions, and a job as the progress someone is trying to make toward a goal in particular circumstances. The research uncovers the story behind a decision instead of asking people why they made it.

The Institute's best-known example is a fast-food restaurant that found morning customers were hiring milkshakes to satisfy hunger, make a drive more interesting and eat easily in the car. The competition was bananas and bagels, not other milkshakes. (Nobody's product roadmap had "be more like a banana" on it.)

Bob Moesta and Chris Spiek say they created the switch interview used below and the four forces model that goes with it (jobstobedone.org).

A B2B job never mentions your product

Write a job from the customer's side without naming what you sell. (These examples are hypothetical.)

SituationJobWhat gets hired today
A veterinary clinic runs out of a vaccine in a busy weekHelp me know what we have before a vet needs it, without counting shelves every FridayA spreadsheet and the practice manager's memory
A controller finds a cost overrun after a job has closedHelp me see which jobs are going over while I can still actWeekly exports and a pivot table
A new VP of sales inherits a messy pipeline weeks before a board meetingHelp me show the board a forecast I can defendAn analyst's weekend and a slide deck

Each job carries more than a function: the VP needs a working forecast and also wants to look credible at a first board meeting. That social and emotional side often decides between two tools that do the same thing.

The third column is your real competition: spreadsheets, extra staff hours and doing nothing, as well as other software. Competitor analysis covers researching those alternatives.

Four forces decide whether anyone switches

Moesta and Spiek's four forces model says a customer switches only when push and pull outweigh anxiety and habit:

  • Push of the situation: the frustration that makes the current way unacceptable.
  • Pull of the new solution: the better situation the customer can picture.
  • Anxiety of the new solution: worry that the new option won't work, or that they will look foolish.
  • Habit of the present: comfort with the current way, even when it is bad.

They argue that most teams work on pull and neglect anxiety and habit. In the veterinary example, a clinic might love the idea of automatic stock counts (pull) and still stay put because nobody wants to re-enter every product code (habit), or because a wrong count could leave a vet short of a drug mid-surgery (anxiety).

A switch interview guide for the veterinary example

The switch interview reconstructs one real decision as a timeline. Moesta and Spiek's guide recommends recruiting people who switched in the last 30 to 90 days (including people who almost switched and didn't), planning 45 to 90 minutes, and expecting patterns to start appearing within 5 to 8 interviews for a given job. Their timeline runs from first thought through passive looking, a first event, active looking and a second event, to the decision, purchase and use. A guide that follows it:

  1. Set the scene. "I'd like to reconstruct exactly what happened, like a documentary. The small details help."
  2. Find the first thought. "When did you first think the way you tracked stock had to change? What was going on before that?" Moesta and Spiek say people usually report a moment later than the real first thought, so keep asking what came before.
  3. Passive looking. "Before you went looking, did you notice other ways of doing this? Where?"
  4. The first event. "What happened that made you decide to actually do something?"
  5. Active looking. "What did you look at? What did you rule out, and why?"
  6. The second event. "What made you decide then, rather than next quarter?"
  7. Anxiety and habit. "What almost stopped you? What did you worry would go wrong?"
  8. After the purchase. "What was the first week like? What surprised you?"

Keep asking "and then what happened?" and write down their exact words. Moesta and Spiek advise against feeding customers your vocabulary: "I was sick of counting on Fridays" is more useful than your label for it.

Write the job in the customer's words

After five or more interviews, lay the timelines side by side and look for the same push, the same kind of first event and the same worries. Then write the job in their terms: "When [situation], help me [progress], so I can [outcome], without [what I fear]."

Compare that sentence with what your product and marketing actually say. How to analyze customer interviews covers comparing notes across a round.

A buyer persona describes who takes part in a purchase; the job describes what they are trying to get done and why they switched when they did. A customer journey map then shows how they move through your sales and onboarding.

Your next step

List people who switched to your product, to a competitor or to a workaround in the last three months, and book five switch interviews. If the recent switchers you need are outside your network, Instant Expert can find people who match a description such as "practice managers at veterinary clinics who changed how they track inventory this year." It sends your invitations, and you pay for each call that gets booked. See the operations professionals in veterinary services directory page for the kinds of people you could reach.

The switch interview timeline

  1. 1

    First thought

    The moment they first sensed the current way had to change.

  2. 2

    Passive looking

    Noticing other options without actively shopping.

  3. 3

    First event

    Something that turned 'I should look into this' into action.

  4. 4

    Active looking

    Comparing options and working out what they actually care about.

  5. 5

    Second event

    The trigger that moved them from looking to deciding.

  6. 6

    Decision and use

    The purchase, then how the first weeks compared with what they expected.

A switch interview walks one real decision in order, probing backward for the first thought before moving forward to the purchase.