Instant Expert vs Clarity.fm
Clarity.fm sells per-minute calls with experts who listed themselves, so you choose from whoever signed up under a topic. Instant Expert reaches the specific person you need, usually someone who isn't on any marketplace, with one fixed offer for a call or a written answer. You pay only if they book or answer.
You pay only if they book or answer.
Facts about Clarity.fm last checked October 3, 2026, on their own public pages.
The main difference
Clarity is a directory of people who chose to sell advice, sorted by topic. You get whoever signed up under marketing, fundraising or growth, at their per-minute rate. When you need a particular person or a narrow role, the directory can't help, because it can only offer people who made a profile.
Instant Expert starts from the person: the head of logistics at a specific retailer, a former product lead at a company you're studying, a buyer you want to learn from. You name them or describe them precisely, set one price for the call or answer, and pay nothing unless they accept.
Side by side
| Question | Instant Expert | Clarity.fm |
|---|---|---|
| Who you can reach | Specific people you name or describe, whether or not they've signed up for anything. | Experts who created a Clarity profile, mostly in business, marketing, funding and startup topics. |
| How pricing works | You set the price per person (minimum $100 for a 15-minute call or answer, $200 for longer calls), and you're charged only for the people who book or answer. The price includes our fee, and we choose what each person is offered. No subscription. | Each expert sets a per-minute rate. Featured experts on Clarity's browse page ranged from $1.67 to $16.67 per minute. Clarity charges experts a 15% fee on each completed call. |
| When you pay | Only when someone books a call or sends a written answer. Declines and invitations nobody accepts within 7 days cost $0. | When you request the call, for the scheduled rate and length. Cancelling at least 12 hours ahead gets a full refund. |
| Speed | The invitation goes out when you approve the send. People have 7 days to book or answer, with up to two reminders. There's no guarantee a given person says yes. | You request a call and propose times; the expert accepts. Clarity does not publish typical response times. |
| Best for | Talking to one particular person or a narrow role, such as a customer or an industry insider, at a price you set. | General advice from someone who already sells it by the minute. |
Last checked October 3, 2026. Sources: Clarity.fm browse page, Clarity.fm payments and fees help. Prices change; check their sites before you decide.
Where Clarity.fm falls short
Clarity is built around its directory. For reaching a particular person, that leaves gaps:
- It only reaches people who made a Clarity profile, mostly in business, marketing, funding and startup topics. The insider you need may never have listed themselves.
- Profiles are labeled by topic, and a label like SaaS growth doesn't tell you whether the person did the specific work you're asking about. On Instant Expert you describe that experience, such as a past company and role, or name the person.
- The meter runs by the minute at each expert's rate. On Instant Expert you agree one price up front, and you pay it only if they book or answer.
If any listed expert on a broad topic will do, Clarity's per-minute directory is built for that.
You pay only if they book or answer.
How booking on Clarity works
Clarity is browsed by industry. Browse, then Industries, then SaaS lists software advisers with a biography, advice topics and a per-minute rate; one public SaaS adviser profile showed $16.67 a minute. The biography is the only way to tell whether someone did the specific work you're asking about, such as approving a software purchase. On Instant Expert you describe that experience and invite the people who match it.
Clarity's 15% service fee comes out of what the expert receives. It isn't added on top of the rate you see, and the final amount follows the actual call length.
Clarity's help pages disagreed about whether the amount is charged or only authorized when you request a call. On Instant Expert a hold is placed when you send, and the charge happens only when someone books or answers.
Clarity's etiquette asks members to seek advice rather than make unsolicited pitches. Talking about your product to get advice is fine, and a sales conversation can follow if the expert is interested. On Instant Expert you say up front whether you're asking for research, a job introduction or a sales conversation, and the person decides with that in view.
Checked September 26, 2026. Sources: Clarity SaaS directory, A public Clarity SaaS adviser profile, Clarity service fee help, Clarity payments help, How Clarity works, Clarity call etiquette.
Questions
Is Clarity.fm still a good place to get startup advice?
For general advice from whoever is listed, it still works. It falls short when you need a specific person or a narrow role, because it can only offer people who made a profile there. Instant Expert reaches those people directly at work, and you pay only if they book or answer.
How is Instant Expert priced compared with Clarity.fm?
Clarity charges by the minute at each expert's rate and takes 15% from the expert. Instant Expert has one price per person that you set (minimum $100 for a 15-minute call or answer, $200 for longer calls), for a 15, 30, 45 or 60 minute call or a written answer. The price includes our fee, and we choose what each person is offered. You pay only if they accept.
Can I ask for a written answer instead of a call?
On Instant Expert, yes. You can ask for a written or voice answer to one question, and you're charged when the answer arrives. It suits busy people who won't schedule a call but will answer a clear question.
Related
- Expert calls for founders and small teamsAn hour with someone who has already done the thing you're about to try, without a contract.
- Customer discovery interviews with busy professionalsTen to twenty interviews with the people who have the problem, before you build.
- Intro.co and Clarity.fm alternatives: 10 ways to reach people who aren't listedThe best Intro.co and Clarity.fm alternatives for reaching people who aren't listed: expert networks, research panels, Minnect and direct paid invitations.
- How to ask an expert online: free forums work until you need one specific personTo ask an expert online, use a free forum when many people know the answer, and pay for a call when you need one person's experience. Four routes compared.
- Consultant hourly rates: why $55 and $150 can both be fairWhat a consultant hourly rate pays for, public reference points from Upwork and BLS, and how pricing one paid advice call differs from pricing a project.
- How Instant Expert worksRefunds, no-show rules and who you can reach.