10 American Financial Group legal leaders
Matthew Felvus, Vice President, General Counsel & Secretary at Great American Insurance Group, is one of ten American Financial Group legal leaders listed here, alongside a deputy general counsel, the chief compliance officer and assistant general counsels. A reader can learn how legal leaders work at American Financial Group from people who have held the role.
Professionals to explore
Christopher Gaul
LinkedInExperience: Assistant General Counsel & Divisional Senior Vice President · Great American Insurance Group
Christopher Gaul has been Assistant General Counsel & Divisional Senior Vice President at Great American Insurance Group since October 2023. Christopher Gaul has also listed Assistant General Counsel & Divisional Vice President at Great American Insurance Group since April 2020, and the profile is based in Cincinnati, Ohio.
Joe Alter
LinkedInExperience: Vice President, Deputy General Counsel and Secretary · American Financial Group
Joe Alter has been Vice President, Deputy General Counsel and Secretary at American Financial Group since March 2024 and was Assistant Vice President and Deputy General Counsel there from 2023 to 2024. Joe Alter was Senior Vice President, Deputy General Counsel, Board Secretary and Chief Communications Officer at Fifth Third Bank from 2020 to 2023 and Vice President, General Counsel and Corporate Secretary at AK Steel Corporation from 2014 to 2020.
John Fronduti
LinkedInExperience: Assistant General Counsel · Great American Insurance Group
John Fronduti has been Assistant General Counsel at Great American Insurance Group since April 2015 and was Partner at Keating Muething & Klekamp PLL (KMK Law) from 2004 to 2015. John Fronduti was Associate at Keating Muething & Klekamp PLL (KMK Law) from 2001 to 2004 and Associate at Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP from 1997 to 2001.
Katelyn Marshall Abrams
LinkedInExperience: Divisional Assistant Vice President & Assistant General Counsel · Great American Insurance Group
Katelyn Marshall Abrams has been Divisional Assistant Vice President & Assistant General Counsel at Great American Insurance Group since September 2026 and was Senior Counsel there from 2021 to 2026. Katelyn Marshall Abrams was Counsel at Great American Insurance Group from 2019 to 2021 and Associate Counsel there from 2016 to 2019.
Lisa P.
LinkedInExperience: Assistant General Counsel · Great American Insurance Group
Lisa P. has been Assistant General Counsel at Great American Insurance Group since January 2010 and also lists Assistant Vice President there as a role held since 1995. Lisa P. was Corporate Legal Counsel at Great American Insurance Group from 1988 to 1995 and describes experience managing litigation and regulatory matters in a commercial property casualty setting.
Magdalena Grossman
LinkedInExperience: Chief Compliance Officer · American Financial Group
Magdalena Grossman has been Chief Compliance Officer at American Financial Group since April 2025 and has also held Divisional Vice President and Assistant General Counsel at Great American Insurance Group since March 2020. Magdalena Grossman was Divisional Assistant Vice President, Property and Casualty Legal at Great American Insurance Group from 2015 to 2020 and Associate at Hogan Lovells from 2007 to 2015.
Matt Fichter
LinkedInExperience: Div. Asst. Vice President & Assistant General Counsel · Great American Insurance Group
Matt Fichter has been Div. Asst. Vice President & Assistant General Counsel at Great American Insurance Group since March 2020 and was Senior Counsel at National Interstate Insurance Company from 2014 to 2020. Matt Fichter was Corporate Attorney at FirstEnergy from 2012 to 2014 and Attorney at Strachan, Miller & Olender Co., L.P.A. from 2006 to 2012.
Matthew Felvus
LinkedInExperience: Vice President, General Counsel & Secretary · Great American Insurance Group
Matthew Felvus has been Vice President, General Counsel & Secretary at Great American Insurance Group since April 2025 and was Divisional Senior Vice President, Assistant General Counsel & Secretary there from 2022 to 2025. Matthew Felvus was Divisional Vice President, Assistant General Counsel & Secretary at Great American Insurance Group from 2020 to 2022 and Senior Counsel there from 2015 to 2016.
Sarah Ray
LinkedInExperience: Divisional Assistant Vice President, Assistant General Counsel · Great American Insurance Group
Sarah Ray has been Divisional Assistant Vice President, Assistant General Counsel at Great American Insurance Group since January 2025 and was Senior Counsel there from 2021 to 2025. Sarah Ray was Senior Counsel, VP at Fifth Third Bank from 2017 to 2021, Legal Counsel, AVP there from 2016 to 2017 and Contracts Attorney at Medpace from 2014 to 2016.
Thomas King
LinkedInExperience: Div. Asst. Vice President, Assistant General Counsel · Great American Insurance Group
Thomas King has been Div. Asst. Vice President, Assistant General Counsel at Great American Insurance Group since March 2020 and was Corporate Attorney at National Interstate Insurance Company from 2010 to 2020. Thomas King was Associate Attorney at Dan Morell & Associates from 2009 to 2010 and is based in Richfield, Ohio.
Choose the right perspective
Match the person's legal area, such as corporate secretary work, compliance, litigation or property and casualty legal work, to the decision you face. Check when each person started the current role to judge how recent the experience is.
Questions to take into the conversation
- 01What did you focus on first when you took on your current legal role?
- 02How do you decide which legal matters to handle in-house and which to send to outside counsel?
- 03What has your own work taught you about managing outside counsel on claims litigation?
Reaching American Financial Group legal leaders
How can I contact one of these American Financial Group legal leaders?
Pick one of the 10 people on this page and choose "Book a paid call", or describe your project to find others. You offer a fee for a 15-minute call or a written answer, Instant Expert finds the person's work email and sends the invitation, and they decide whether to accept. The list covers 2 companies: Great American Insurance Group and American Financial Group, based on profile data retrieved on October 21, 2026. Being listed here doesn't mean someone has agreed to take calls.
How much does it cost to reach American Financial Group legal leaders?
You choose the offer, starting at $5 per person. The offer is what the person receives, and Instant Expert's fee is added on top, so a $100 offer costs you $125. The fee is 20% of what you pay. You're charged only when the person books the call or sends the answer.
What if they don't reply?
You pay nothing. Instant Expert sends follow-up reminders, and if the person hasn't booked or answered within 7 days, the request expires and any hold on your card is released. You can invite several of the 10 people on this list at once and cap your total spend, so you pay only for the ones who accept.
Can an AI agent ask one of these American Financial Group legal leaders a question?
Yes. An agent with a USDC wallet on Base can ask one question without an Instant Expert account. It names the person, for example by the LinkedIn URL on this page, and pays per ask over x402 (HTTP 402). The person answers in writing or by voice note, and if nobody answers within 7 days, the payment goes back to the wallet automatically. Claude and ChatGPT can do the same through the Instant Expert connector: setup is at /docs/mcp for Claude and /docs/chatgpt for ChatGPT. x402 docs
About this directory
This is a professional research starting point based on business profile data retrieved on . Titles and companies reflect that source snapshot; roles marked former had ended by then. Check the linked profiles for current details. Inclusion does not imply Instant Expert membership or availability.
Request a correction or removal