Channel checks: what distributors can tell you, and where the insider trading line is
Channel checks show how a company is selling by asking distributors, retailers and resellers what they see. Here is how investors run them, and the SEC's limits.
A channel check is a useful early read on how a company is selling, as long as you ask the businesses around it about their own work and never for figures they are bound to protect. It means talking to the distributors, retailers, resellers and suppliers that buy from a company, sell for it or supply it. Investors use channel checks to see how a product is selling before the company reports, how much stock is sitting in the channel and how the company compares with competitors on the shelf. Wikipedia's summary notes that these interviews usually happen without the target company's knowledge, and that analysts look at top products, buying patterns, inventory levels and promotion plans (Channel check).
The SEC has said getting expert advice and analysis through expert networks is legal. Trading on material nonpublic information (MNPI) obtained in breach of a duty to keep it confidential is not.
This page is general information, not legal advice. If you work at a fund or a regulated firm, your compliance team's rules come first.
Here is a made-up example: a canned drinks launch
You cover a public company whose growth depends on a new line of canned sparkling drinks (the company, product and calls are all hypothetical). You want to know whether the drinks are selling through to shoppers or just filling distributor warehouses. (Warehouses order a lot. They drink very little.) You could call:
- Sales reps at beverage distributors in three regions, about how fast retailers are reordering.
- Category buyers at grocery chains, about shelf space and promotions in their stores.
- Independent store and bar owners, about what customers ask for and what sits on the shelf.
- A former distributor manager, about how brands usually launch in this category and what early trouble looks like.
None of them needs to share anything confidential to be useful.
Five steps to a channel check
- Write a testable question. "Is the new line selling through at the pace the company suggested last quarter?" works. "How is the company doing?" does not.
- Pick the roles that see the answer. Distributors see orders and inventory, retailers see shelf movement, suppliers see production volumes.
- Spread the sample across regions, business sizes and channels, so one enthusiastic distributor does not set your view.
- Ask about their own observations. How fast are your stores reordering? What share of your shelf does the category get? What promotions are you running?
- Record and compare. Log each answer with the person's role and region, then compare the pattern with what the company has said publicly. Investor.gov notes that a 10-K's business section, risk factors and management's discussion of known trends are all public on EDGAR (How to read a 10-K).
The expert interview preparation guide covers structuring the call; what to do when two experts disagree helps when channels tell different stories.
The line: ask what they see, never what they must protect
Investor.gov defines illegal insider trading as buying or selling a security, in breach of a fiduciary duty or other relationship of trust and confidence, on the basis of material, nonpublic information. It also covers tipping that information and trading by the person tipped (Investor.gov: Insider trading).
In 2011 the SEC charged hedge fund managers and analysts with trading on confidential information from technology company employees who were moonlighting as consultants for an expert network firm, a scheme the SEC said netted more than $30 million. Its statement in that case is the clearest summary of the rule: "it is legal to obtain expert advice and analysis through expert networking arrangements, it is illegal to trade on material nonpublic information obtained in violation of a duty to keep that information confidential" (SEC News Digest, February 8, 2011). By June 2012 the SEC said its expert network investigation had produced actions against 23 defendants, with alleged illicit gains of more than $117 million (SEC press release 2012-121).
In practice:
- Do not call employees of the company itself about its sales, orders or results. In the 2011 case, the tips came from employees of the companies being traded.
- Do not ask anyone for numbers they are bound to protect, such as a distributor's contracted volumes with the brand or a retailer's confidential sales data. Ask what they see and do in their own work.
- Stop if someone starts sharing restricted information. Change the subject, end the call if it continues, and tell your compliance team.
- Keep notes of who you spoke with, what you asked and what they said, for compliance to review.
If your firm needs call-level controls, use a managed network
GLG, for example, says its experts sign terms each year agreeing not to give clients confidential information, including material non-public information, and to stop any project that moves into subjects they cannot discuss. It says employed experts may not take part in projects about their own employer, and that clients can use a compliance dashboard to pre-approve calls or add their own screening questions (GLG compliance).
That is likely the better fit if your firm requires call-level pre-approval, chaperoned calls or transcript review. The expert network companies overview compares the main firms.
Your next step
Write your channel check question in one sentence and list three roles in the channel that would see the answer in their own work. Draft five questions about what those people observe, and have compliance review them before you book anything.
If you can describe the people you need, such as "sales reps at beverage distributors in the Southeast," Instant Expert finds people who match and you review them before anything is sent. Put your boundary in the invitation note, because it is the first thing they read: say you want their own observations of reorders and shelf movement, and nothing confidential about any brand. You can also add people you must not contact to your do-not-contact list.
You set what each person receives, and our fee (20% of what you pay) is added on top: a $200 offer for a 30-minute call costs you $250. Say you invite six reps across three regions. Sending places a hold on your card for one person's price, and each rep is charged only when they book, so the most the six can cost is $1,500, and declines cost nothing. The directory pages for sales professionals in beverages, procurement professionals in beverages and sales professionals in grocery retail are a place to start. For diligence on a private company, see commercial due diligence.
If you work in the channel and get an invitation
The invitation shows the investor's note and the amount you would receive, which is yours in full; the buyer pays our fee on top. Read the note before you accept. If answering would mean sharing your employer's contracted volumes or a customer's confidential data, decline, or answer only from what you see in your own work. You can take a call or send a written or voice answer, and you have 7 days to respond. Payment goes out 24 hours after the call, by direct deposit, a gift card or a donation to a charity you pick.