Customer advisory board: how to run one where customers do 80% of the talking

A customer advisory board works when executives mostly listen. Pick a model, invite peers and a few critics, run meetings that end in decisions.

Instant Expert EditorialPublished Updated 7 min read

A customer advisory board (CAB) works when your executives spend most of each meeting listening, then act on what they hear. It is a small group of customers who meet with your leadership team on a regular schedule to advise on strategy, product direction and how their own businesses are changing. Members are usually senior people at customer companies, and they usually take part without pay.

A CAB is different from a startup advisory board, which is a handful of individual advisors, often paid in equity, who help founders with gaps such as fundraising or a first sales hire. CAB members advise as customers, about the problem you solve for them. Startup advisors advise about running the company.

Pick one of two models on purpose

The strategic CAB. Insight Partners, writing with CAB strategist Mike Gospe, describes a CAB as a program rather than a meeting, focused on strategic questions that will matter two to three years out (Insight Partners). It is not meant to be a product focus group, a customer appreciation event or a sales meeting. Your executives should spend about 80% of the time listening.

The early-stage CAB. Peter Kazanjy, interviewed by First Round Review, describes an early CAB as an extension of customer discovery: a group representing the people you expect to sell to, including prospects, whom you can send quick surveys, mockups and prototypes and invite to occasional dinners. Kazanjy's second company's CAB included representatives from 80 companies. (That is a lot of dinners.)

Strategic CABEarly-stage CAB
MembersSenior leaders at existing customersTarget buyers and users, including prospects
SizeTypically 10 to 15 customers, per Wikipedia; Insight suggests inviting 8 to 12Can be large; Kazanjy's had 80 companies
Contact1 to 2 meetings a year of half a day or more, or a few 90-minute virtual sessionsAbout once a month, under an hour, plus quarterly events
TopicsStrategy, how members' businesses are changing, roadmap directionWhether the problem is real, features, pricing, naming
Signs you are readyInsight's list includes having more than 50 paying customers and executives ready to act on what they hearYou have finished a round of discovery interviews and want to keep the best interviewees involved

Invite peers who can speak for their company, plus a few critics

  • People who can speak for their company's direction. Wikipedia's overview stresses picking both the right customer company and the right individual within it. For a strategic CAB, Insight suggests C-suite representatives.
  • A balanced group of peers. Sierra Ventures recommends building membership around your ideal customer profile and balancing perspectives. It warns against a mix so wide that members no longer feel among peers, such as a Fortune 500 CEO alongside a small-business head of HR (Sierra Ventures).
  • A few critics. Wikipedia notes that membership can benefit from a few outspoken customers who have complained in the past. A board made only of your happiest accounts is likely to confirm what you already believe.
  • For an early-stage CAB, the people who feel the problem most. Kazanjy recruited the interviewees who had confirmed the problem most strongly, and warns that if people won't join, you may be aiming too senior: directors, managers and daily users often engage more than senior executives.

Members join for influence, so check before offering gifts

Wikipedia lists the usual benefits as influence over the company's direction, prestige, networking with each other and with company officers, and a chance to share practices. Insight's BigPanda example adds that members who have never met need icebreakers and social time before they open up.

Check before you offer anything of value. Sierra Ventures cautions that many large customers prohibit their employees from taking compensation in any form. For longer surveys and tests, Kazanjy says the company valued members' time at $100 an hour, paid in gift cards. Whatever you choose, apply it to every member.

Run each meeting so it ends in decisions

  1. Write a charter. Insight recommends an internal charter that aligns your executives and a customer-friendly version for members, covering objectives and expectations, with at least three months between internal kickoff and the first meeting.
  2. Send a few big questions ahead. Share background material beforehand so members arrive ready to discuss, not to watch slides.
  3. Let customers talk. Aim for the 80/20 split. In Insight's BigPanda example, virtual sessions worked best with 6 to 8 people; with more, two or three voices could dominate while half the group stayed silent. A neutral outside facilitator can stop one customer from taking over.
  4. Close the loop. Open each meeting with what you did with the last round of advice, and what you chose not to do. Wikipedia notes that a CAB's credibility depends on following through on key recommendations, or giving a reason for not doing so. Kazanjy's updates to members cover what the company said it would do last time and whether it did.

Keep competitors' prices and plans out of the room

If members' companies compete, steer discussion away from their prices and future plans. The FTC warns that exchanging price or other sensitive business data among competitors, including through an industry group, can raise antitrust concerns, and that information about future plans should be closely guarded (FTC). Discussing industry trends and your own product is normal. If members compete, ask your lawyer to review the charter. This is general information, not legal advice.

A CAB only hears from customers who stayed

Members are usually your most engaged and senior customers. Insight says a CAB is not the place to find out why customers are churning. Nor will it explain lost deals, or how buyers who never considered you see the market. Fill those gaps separately: interview customers who chose another product, interview customers who stopped using your product, and talk to people in the market who are not your customers. Voice of customer covers how these sources fit together.

A made-up example: a CAB for pharmacy software

A company with about 120 customers sells inventory software to hospital pharmacies. It needs to decide whether to build for health systems with ten or more hospitals, where it has few customers. It sets up a strategic CAB of ten:

  • Six pharmacy directors at current customers, including two who complained about integrations last year.
  • Two pharmacy leaders at multi-hospital systems that are current customers.
  • Two hospital supply chain leaders who work with the pharmacy team.

It meets once a year in person for half a day, with two 90-minute virtual sessions in between. The first big question is: "How will decisions about pharmacy software be made in your organization over the next three years?" None of the members can explain why large health systems chose a competitor, so the product team separately interviews five systems that did.

Your next step

Write the two or three strategic questions you most need customers to answer in the next year. If you can name them, your executives will act on the answers and you match Insight's readiness signs in the table, set up a strategic CAB. If you are still testing whether the problem is real, start with the lighter early-stage model.

If you have never run a CAB, or you need perspectives from outside your customer base, a few calls can help. Describe the people, such as "customer success leaders who have run a customer advisory board at a B2B software company" or "pharmacy directors at multi-hospital health systems," and Instant Expert finds people who match. The directory pages for chief customer officers and hospital supply chain experts are one place to start.

An outside person is paid for one conversation, with nothing owed after it. You set what they receive, our fee is added on top (a $100 offer costs you $125), and you're charged only if they book. The Sierra Ventures caution above applies here too: if someone's employer restricts outside payments, they can choose a donation to a charity they pick instead, where their employer's policy allows it. We make the donation, and your charge is the same.