SWOT analysis: four lists of opinions until you check them

A SWOT analysis is only as good as its evidence. Use this template and worked example, check each item with customers and industry people, then turn it into actions.

Instant Expert EditorialPublished Updated 6 min read

A SWOT analysis is only as good as the evidence behind it, and one written in a meeting room has none. It lists an organization's strengths and weaknesses, which are internal, and the opportunities and threats it faces, which are external. That version records what the team already believes. Checked with customers and people who know the industry, it shows which of those beliefs hold up.

1. Start with the grid, then add an evidence table

The basic layout is a two-by-two grid. The University of Kansas Community Tool Box guide to SWOT uses the same split: strengths and weaknesses are internal, opportunities and threats come from outside. It notes the method was first developed for business and industry, and that its strengths are simplicity and wide application.

HelpfulHarmful
Internal (things you control)StrengthsWeaknesses
External (things you do not control)OpportunitiesThreats

The grid hides the evidence, so keep a second table as your working copy, one row per item:

ItemS, W, O or TWhy we believe itWho could confirm or reject itWhat they saidConfirmed by

The last three columns turn a list of opinions into something you can act on.

2. Write a fast first draft (parts of it will be wrong)

Here is a made-up example; the company, its customers and the interview results are all hypothetical. You run a 20-person company making custom printed corrugated boxes for regional food producers such as bakeries, coffee roasters and snack makers. You are deciding whether to buy a second digital press.

The leadership team's first draft:

HelpfulHarmful
InternalS1. Short runs are cheap for us. S2. We turn orders around faster than big converters. S3. Customers love our design help.W1. One salesperson brings in most new accounts. W2. Our website does not show prices or minimums. W3. The press is at capacity in the fourth quarter.
ExternalO1. More small food brands are selling online and need shipping boxes. O2. Retailers are asking suppliers for recyclable packaging.T1. Large converters are adding short-run digital printing. T2. Paperboard prices can move quickly. T3. A big customer could bring packaging in-house.

Every item is the team's opinion. (S3 is the kind of thing every company believes about itself.)

3. Check each item with the people who would know

The Community Tool Box says to identify strengths and weaknesses from outsiders' point of view too, including the people you serve, because they may see problems or assets you do not. Opportunities and threats need people who watch the market:

  • Strengths and weaknesses: customers and lost prospects. Ask five or six customers why they chose you and what nearly made them leave. Ask two or three prospects who went elsewhere why. S3 counts as confirmed only if customers bring it up without being prompted.
  • Opportunities: buyers in the market you want to grow into. For O1, talk to founders or operations leads at small online food brands. Ask what boxes they use now, how they buy them and what goes wrong.
  • Threats: industry people. For T1 and T2, talk to packaging buyers at larger food companies and people who have worked at paperboard mills or large converters. Ask what they have seen, not what they predict. If you talk to a competitor's former employees, say up front that you do not want confidential information; competitive intelligence covers the rules.

The SBA's market research guidance lists in-depth interviews alongside surveys and focus groups, and notes that asking customers yourself can reveal where they might go instead. For a SWOT, a handful of interviews beats a survey because you need the reasons behind each answer. Interviews vs. surveys covers the trade-off.

After those conversations, the working table might read:

ItemWhat people saidConfirmed byChange
S2. Fast turnaroundCustomers named speed first as why they chose you5 of 6 customersKeep; lead with it
S3. Design helpMentioned unprompted by 1 of 6; the others handle design themselves1 of 6Downgrade
W2. No prices onlineTwo lost prospects chose a supplier that showed minimums up front2 of 3 lost prospectsKeep; fix first
O1. Online food brandsAll three brand founders buy stock boxes online and want small printed runs3 of 3Keep
T1. Large converters adding digitalOne packaging buyer was offered short runs by a large converter1 of 2 industry peopleKeep as a watch item

The counts are hypothetical, but the rule is simple. An item most of the people who would know confirm stays. An item nobody outside the company mentions moves to "unconfirmed" until you find evidence.

The Community Tool Box suggests cutting each list to the best 10 or fewer points. After checking, you may have three or four per box.

4. Turn the grid into actions with a TOWS matrix

A SWOT that ends as a grid changes nothing. The Community Tool Box describes a TOWS matrix, adapted from Fred David's Strategic Management text, that pairs items to produce actions:

StrengthsWeaknesses
OpportunitiesUse strengths to pursue opportunities. S1 + S2 + O1: offer a fast, low-minimum printed mailer for online food brands.Use opportunities to fix weaknesses. W2 + O1: publish prices and minimums for the new mailer so small brands can order without calling.
ThreatsUse strengths to defend against threats. S2 + T1: promise and track turnaround times, since speed is the reason customers gave.Reduce weaknesses that make threats worse. W1 + T3: add a second person to account management so one departure does not cost the biggest accounts.

In the example, the evidence supports the second press only if the online-brand opportunity turns into orders. So publish prices for a small-run mailer and see whether orders arrive before buying the press.

5. Watch for the two ways a SWOT misleads

The Community Tool Box gives two cautions. A SWOT describes your current position, so it can steer you toward what you already do. And it is easy to use one to justify a decision already made. Checking items with outsiders guards against both. It also warns that an opportunity can become a threat if everyone else chases it too, so ask industry people about that directly.

For forces a SWOT may skip, such as how much power suppliers or buyers have, use Porter's five forces. For specific competitors, use a competitive analysis template.

Your next step

Write your first-draft SWOT in 20 minutes. Next to each item, write who outside could confirm or reject it. Then book conversations with five customers, two or three lost prospects and two people who know the industry, and update the grid with what they say.

If you do not know the industry people, Instant Expert can find people who match a description you write, such as "packaging buyers at mid-sized food manufacturers." You review who it finds, it sends your invitations, and you pay only for calls that get booked. The directory pages for procurement professionals in packaging and sales professionals in packaging are one place to start.